It’s Techie Without a Clue getting all philosophical again. Today’s subject is Cyberspace. Basically, what is it? How can we possibly understand it? We can look at the subject in many ways. Rationally, it is nothing more than millions of electronic files stored in millions of computers.
In this form, Cyberspace doesn’t actually exist. It is just a word used to explain the interchange of information from those files on the web. Yet, if we accept this reductionist explanation alone, then the ‘interchange’ has no reality.
This is plainly preposterous. The interchange is real. It does happen. So for it to happen, it must have reality, but a reality that cannot be grasped in any rational or, indeed, scientific, understanding.
The processes behind ecology may be helpful. Ecology is about eco-systems – the interplay of lifeforms within an environment. Science would study the individual lifeforms or the environment itself. Ecology searches for the relationship within the interplay.
Again, we are talking of something that doesn’t really exist, but obviously does. It is simply not registered in any form of understanding to science. It’s similar to, say, love, which clearly exists, but cannot be measured.
Maybe fictional representations of Cyberspace can help. Increasingly Cyberspace is being represented as some parallel world ‘out there.’ Within it, superheroes react with forces of good and bad.
This has echoes of the mysticism behind the religious impulse. Religion is thought to have begun with animism, the idea that a spiritual world lies parallel to the physical, populated by spirits of the physical forms.
This idea eventually led to the Classical mythologies and the existence of an ‘other-world’ that guides us, defines our morality, and shows us the information which allows us to make sense of the world.
Guess what. That is increasingly an explanation of the internet and this mythological Cyberspace. Are we birthing a new, electronic God-force? Or is cyberspace just millions of individual files in millions of different places?
If you opt for the latter, then this debate doesn’t exist.
© Anthony North, Feb 2007
Blogging Index