BEYOND THE BLOG

HOW TO DO DOCTOR WHO – HERO

Posted by anthonynorth on April 6, 2008

As the new series of Doctor Who aired its first episode last night, it might be instructive to look at why it is so successful. And the simple fact is, whether consciously or unconsciously, the writers, including Russell T Davies, have rebirthed one of the earliest known psychic forms.
This all revolves around the character of Doctor Who himself. For instance, several things are peculiar about him. The first is his apparent amorality. Whilst he is always saving the world, his morals seem to be distant in terms of normal relationships.

This is particularly noticeable in his love life.

Or should I say, lack of it. Even when he got ‘close’ to Rose Tyler in a previous series, the only emotion was expressed between parallel universes, where any form of physical contact was impossible.
In this sense, the character is almost a ‘fetish’. And when we combine his amorality and distance with the actual things he does, his entire being fits into a simple storytelling device.

Doctor Who is, quite literally, a god.

Appearing human, but clearly not, he flits in and out of reality, and exists in time and space, armed with ‘magical’ weapons such as his sonic screwdriver, and traveling in his ‘magical’ chariot, or TARDIS.
However, we can even identify him more closely than this. For in myths throughout the ancient world, there is a specific god-character that is at the heart of the supernatural story.

This is the Hero.

From Hercules to Gilgamesh, from Osiris to King Arthur, from Quetzalcoatl to Beowulf, the Hero appears, completes a miraculous task, often involving vanquishing a monster, and saves, or changes, society for the better. The Dalek, it seems, is Grendel in tin foil.
Sometimes the Hero is also the Stranger, and in this form he has multiple adventures, forever remaining aloof from the society itself, thus always being the amoral, fetish-like outsider.

This symbolic form is even in the East.

Hindu Avatars such as Chrishna and Rama share similar characteristics. And this story-form is vital for understanding much of human psychology itself.
Through the work of mythologists such as Joseph Campbell, we know its absolute universality, and with Carl Jung devising his idea of a ‘collective unconscious’ populated by ‘archetypes’, the secret of the form is disclosed.

It is, in effect, a story of human aspiration.

Perhaps, even, the first story, with adaptations even stretching into the spiritual, particularly with the story of Christ, the stranger who came from God, and changed society through his heroic sacrifice.
Indeed, the story is so fundamental to our psyche that when placed in a fictional character-form, it seems to transcend its images or words, and connects deep within the inner mind, thus confirming it popularity.
But more than this, the story is timeless, as the Doctor is himself. And in this sense, it is psychic influence upon culture. And when we think of the heroes and monsters from psychical, Gothic, and other story forms, and the spin-off paranormal experiences that are then witnessed, the connection between culture and experience is confirmed.

© Anthony North, April 2008

20 Responses to “HOW TO DO DOCTOR WHO – HERO”

  1. Selma said

    There is certainly a mythological element to the Doctor. Perhaps that is why he is so appealing. Or maybe it’s because he is just so darn cute!

  2. Hi Selma,
    Don’t see it myself, though all the females in my household are Tennantites! :-)
    Seriously, I think he transcends cute. He’s got a natural charisma.

  3. spiderstu said

    I’ve always thought of Doctor Who (especially since the re-launch) as being a very epic story. I also love the last of his race connotations that they’ve threaded in, in the last few years. I think it becomes more and more apparent with each season that despite all his power he is a very lonely character, which makes him more likable for some reason.

  4. Hi Spiderstu,
    Absolutely. In one way he is the ultimate Outsider. And his loneliness is, at times, profound.

  5. CD said

    Then again, maybe it’s just better writing and storyline than the other tripe on the tube.

  6. manic mo said

    Is this the season premiere with Kylie Minogue?
    We’re just getting previews for it now on BBC America!
    Is Martha Jones in this season still?

  7. Hi CD,
    An important factor, certainly. But the best type of writing takes the above into account.

    Hi Mo,
    We had the Kylie one at Christmas as a one-off special. The other day we had the first of the new series proper.
    The main assistant is Donna (Catherine Tate) who appeared in The Runaway Bride episode. But according to the publicity, he’s being joined at times by Martha, Captain Jack and even Rose Tyler.
    Still looks good.

  8. Two Words Tony
    David Tennant
    :-)

  9. Brenda said

    Martha went to Torchwood for a few episodes. Been waiting for the New Who to start!! I guess that is on or about APril 18th for us here in North America.

    All the Doctors were hot even the old farts!! Its the mystery and the elements he brigns with him.

    What a plot twist it would be to see a “new” Doctor emerge sometime from the bowels of the Tardis. Anyone game for a female Doctor or like the president will that ever happen??

    Just a though. ;-)

  10. Hi Anita Marie,
    Oh dear, another Tennantite :-)
    The guy has charisma, no doubt about that. Even I like him.

    Hi Brenda,
    So have I got this right? If Amercia gets a female President, she’s from the bowels of … :-)
    No seriously, I remember as a kid when Doctor Who first began, with ‘old fart’ Hartnell. It was brilliant then. Lost its way eventually, and deserved to be axed. But under Russell T Davies it’s magnificent.

  11. [...] Tony did and it’s a post as well written as the rest of his work HERE [...]

  12. Paolo said

    Hi

    I really enjoyed this. I have often viewed the good Doctor as an avatar of Mercury/Hermes/Thoth.

    Cheers Paolo

  13. Hi Paolo,
    Yes, the old mythological archetypes just keep on appearing in storytelling, regardless of culture.

  14. seasoned8 said

    You’re right…Tennonite.

    In the 50+ years that the “Good Doctor” has been battling the forces of evil who dwell in the depths of the universe and always seem intent on somehow enslaving, destroying and or consuming the human population of planet Earth, there have been a few actors less attractive physically, but not necessarily mentally.

    After all, smart is attractive too.

  15. Hi Seasoned8,
    Smart is, indeed, attractive. How many authors, for instance, have attracted the most beautiful people?
    Can’t wait for my bestseller ;-)

  16. TiBoT said

    I like your argument, but he’s just a super hero with a different cape. They all posses special powers and all that mumbo jumbo about being pure of heart, etc., etc. The show features great story lines, great acting, special effects with a bit of nostalgia thrown in for good measure (Sarah Jane Smith still looks great 30 years on!) It’s just a lot of fun, and it’s one of the few shows on TV that our entire family watches together.

  17. Phil said

    good for follow up reading;

    Joseph Campbell – Hero With a Thousand Faces

  18. Hi TiBoT,
    That’s certainty true.

    Hi Phil,
    A classic book, indeed. The best in its field.

  19. baz said

    hi anthony

    i can definetly say that i am a cult follower of, “dr who”. watched the first episode back in the 50’s with, “william hartnell”. along with “dan dare” and “journey into space”. they all helped to open up my horizons. back in the early days it was aimed at a simpler audience, with younger companions, no need for long term relationships. after it was decided he could change looks and personality, his character evolved and the companions became older with a hint of relationship, even more so with rose tyler.

    what makes the show so endearing is we wish we had imortality, and the ability to change world’s and help people and slay the well defined villans, i.e. “daleks”, maybe even the days of empire as it’s set in a britain that still matters. another thing is it portrays the family as an important part of life, even though it often seems today that striving individuals are praised most, i think we want to be liked and belong though, so for 60 minutes we enjoy something wholesome and familiar.

    remember you are god

    baz

  20. Hi Baz,
    That’s a very good analysis, and I don’t think I can disagree with any of it. Some of those old Sci Fi series were damned good, weren’t they?

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>