TONY ON DATA-TOTALITARIANISM & MORE
Posted by anthonynorth on November 24, 2008
Including Thursday Thirteen, Monday Mural, Totally Optional Prompts, Heads or Tails and Search Engine Stories. Have you had a go yet?
Some recent headlines from the UK. Up to a million public-sector workers could be allowed access to sensitive information on databases concerning every child. The government plans to allow medical researchers access to personal details on databases. Who owns this information?
It is all to do with privacy.
Do I have a right to keep my personal details private? Freedom in my country was built upon the premise that as long as I pay my taxes, obey a fair common law and defend my country, no one has the right to anything concerning me, or hinder, in any way, what I want to do.
This no longer seems to be the case. Rather, the personal has been digitalized and we all exist in a collective information pool. Add to this the increasing surveillance measures being imposed through fear of crime and terrorism, and my right to privacy is now becoming void.
This is a huge contradiction.
And not only of freedom. We are said to live in the age of the individual and individual rights, yet the reality is the individual is being deconstructed and placed into a pool of citizenry to be spied on and controlled as a government sees fit.
Increasing technology made this state of affairs inevitable. A government will always try to grab rights over the individual in order to control him. In many ways our only defence against this urge towards totalitarianism is the privacy of our selves and family.
Information technology has decimated this natural societal defence mechanism. The need to know has supplanted the demand that we mind our own business. This growing impulse needs to be debated and questioned while we still have the right to say it is going on.
Next post, Thursday. Hope to see you then.
© Anthony North, November 2008
TT #32 – WINDOWS
Windows are eyes that stare at you,
or portals to others, if you look through;
mediums that connect you to more,
seclusion something they totally abhor;
Windows show how things can be,
allowing alternative ways to see,
the beauty of how others exist,
or horrors disclosed, they always persist;
But what if you’re neither here nor there,
just seeing a reflection when you stare,
caught in a world trapped in their glare,
a window to nothing from nowhere?
Shatter the glass! Escape! If you dare
(c) Anthony North, November 2008
******************************
HANDYMAN – Fiction
‘Look what I can do with my hands,’ said Jimmy when he was a kid. And there he was, making gestures from the funny to the obscene. And later, when he found a new use for his hands, he’d supplement it by pulling girls’ pigtails. He never really grasped the deeper impulses of what he was doing.
I suppose that’s why, later, he used his hands to become a bully, hitting out, declaring I’m the big guy around here. He was challenged once when someone else used their hands, but Jimmy settled that score in a dark alley, using his hands to hold the baseball bat.
Using his hands was the making of Jimmy. Not in the way it should – he never used them to be a carpenter, or builder, or anything useful – but to perfect how to break into that house, how to mug someone fast, and occasionally using his feet to get away.
When he met the love of his life, he used his hand more gently – until she decided she had a life and opinions of her own. That’s when he started using his hands to batter her.
Of course, she eventually had enough, and she used her mouth to tell the police everything about him. He used his hands to escape when they tried to arrest him, laying three of them out before making it back to seek revenge.
That’s when he used his hands to throttle her – which was nearly the end of the story of Jimmy. Except that something strange happened to him and he used his hands one more time – to pull the trigger and blow his brains out.
Well, I say brains, but that was the problem with Jimmy. Always his hands. Never his head.
© Anthony North, November 2008
BUTTERFLY SKIES
I watch them flutter where I lie,
butterflies filling the deep blue sky,
coming so close, I could almost touch,
and I love them all, oh, so much;
A strange empathy I seem to share,
these creatures looking so colourful and fair,
harbingers of better days,
frolicking in a summer haze;
But why do they seem to fly by me,
is there something I just can’t see?
Why do I feel so strange and new?
Who took my legs? New thoughts imbue;
Oh!
I’m no longer a caterpillar; I’m a butterfly, too
(c) Anthony North, November 2008
This entry was posted on November 24, 2008 at 11:18 pm and is filed under Current Affairs, Poetry, Social Awareness, Society. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Chris said
Hi Anthony,
I am sure that the common good is not best served by power and cotrol (domination). It is best served by freedom, creative growth and mutual respect. Metamorphosis is always possible (I’m still an optimist)!
Chris said
Hi Anthony,
Control, control, control!! 🙂
anthonynorth said
Hi Chris,
That’s the way to be – and the exact opposite of practically every predominant social and political power in history.
Whether they can spell or not 😉
Comedy Plus said
Scared me to death. Pretty soon we will just all be a number. Big brother will know everything that we do. I don’t like that one bit. Reminds of some of those sci-fiction movies. Perhaps one day they won’t be sci-fiction anymore. Have a great day Anthony. 🙂
anthonynorth said
Hi Sandee,
Yes, it’s terrible. It doesn’t get scarier.
Geraldine said
Lovely take on Selma’s butterfly prompt Anthony. Touching, light-hearted and inspiring. Hugs, G
anthonynorth said
Hi Geraldine,
Thanks for that. Much appreciated.
bundleocontradictions said
Wow! Once again, you’ve done something wonderful with words.
Sue said
Very creative take on the theme 🙂 You are a wonderful writer!
Travis said
There was an episode of The West Wing in the first season that dealt with the appointment of a new justice to the US Supreme Court. The issue of privacy was front and center…the judge candidate did not believe the right to privacy was explicit in the Constitution, and therefore he could not rule in favor of any case on the merit of such a right.
The show concluded that the right to privacy would be one of the central issues of the 21st century. The original candidate was discarded in favor of a different judge who believed that the right to privacy, though not specifically enumerated, lived in several passages of the Bill of Rights.
Although that program was fiction, I tend to agree with the premise that the right to privacy will be one of the central issues of our time.
Skittles said
It’s too bad he didn’t use what little brain power he had instead of his hands..
Karen said
Great idea on uses of hands.
Selma said
The whole Big Brother syndrome really scares me. There are certain aspects of our lives that should remain private and not in some government database. I know it almost sounds very Orwellian to say so but it’s almost as if the government doesn’t want us to retain our individuality any more. Maybe we’re just ‘making up the numbers.’ Sometimes I do fear for the future.
I liked your window poem – a window to nowhere. Quite eerie. Your story gives an entirely new meaning to the word handyman. Yikes!
Your poem about butterflies is so lovely. They are indeed harbingers of better days. A wonderful post!
anthonynorth said
Hi Bundleocontradictions,
Thank you for those kind words. They are much appreciated.
Hi Sue,
Many thanks. You are far too kind.
Hi Travis,
I think you’re right. I once heard a politician put much of the problem like this: In the old days, no one had privacy because there were only small communities and everyone knew everyone else. The problem of privacy in today’s world is that the small community has gone and now we live in a huge one. But the same impulses remain, only bigger.
So in this context, we naturally have no right to privacy, because we never had it in the first place. But there are two problems to this – mass information is more fundamental than natural curiosity of a community; and that community was not an authority. It was simply human nature doing what it does. Investing information in an authority is a different matter altogether.
Hi Skittles,
This is indeed so. And all too often this scenario isn’t fiction at all.
Hi Karen,
Thanks for that. Glad you liked it.
Hi Selma,
I’m certain ‘individuality’, as presently expressed, is just something conjured up as a consumer ploy. It is different to ‘privacy’, and maybe that’s why it can so easily be manipulated by authority.
Thanks for the kind words about the story and poems.
SandyCarlson said
Oh, geez. We are part of a data pool and the so-called life guards are watching us because we are interesting rather than because they want to keep us safe. Does not warm the cockles of my heart!
Tina said
always love reading your stories. that is a great meaning to the story ‘using your hands and not your head’ loved the build up to the end 😉
anthonynorth said
Hi Sandy,
You put it well. A kind of techno-voyeurism, I suppose.
Hi Tina,
Thanks for that. I’m pleased you liked the story.
Hootin' Anni said
Oh Anthony…that “Handyman” was maybe fiction but so real to true life it really opened my eyes this morning. Another excellent entry.
My ‘hands’ Heads or Tails is published. But you’ll have to scroll down beyond the last of my King’s Ranch series of photos.
anthonynorth said
Hi Hootin’ Anni,
Thanks for those kind words. They are much appreciated.
Twilight said
On the privacy issue – I’m not unduly worried about the government having access to my details – after going through the US immigration hoop-la over the past 4 years, they know just about everything there is to know about me – it’s not very interesting anyway. I do strongly object to other bodies having access though, without specific permission from me. It’s a scary prospect in some ways, but the day somebody invented computer technology, it was, as you say, AN, an inevitable consequence. It doesn’t scare me as much as global warming and its likely consequences though.
So much to worry about – so little time…. 😉
Good story, AN. So much in just 3 paras! “Butterfly Skies” has a lovely delicate feel to it – just like a butterfly. 🙂
Anna said
Unfortunately there are way too many people like Jimmy in this world.
anthonynorth said
Hi Anna,
There are indeed – which is a great tragedy.
Michelle Johnson said
Good morning, Anthony! Hope all is well with you today. I too fear where our privacy laws will be in the coming years. I have to wonder why the wars for freedom were fought if we can’t have the choice or freedom to choose what information is shared with the general public. I can only hope that people will stand up for themselves now while they still can. Loved your poems. Have a nice day.
anthonynorth said
Hi Michelle,
I hope so too, because it’s beginning to get quite serious.
And I am very well, thank you.
Shannon H. said
You have a great way with words!
anthonynorth said
Hi Shannon,
Thanks for that. I’m pleased you think so. It’s much appreciated.
anthonynorth said
Hi Twilight,
For some reason your comment was gobbled up by the Great WordPress Comment Eater. Still, I fought it and got it out! 🙂
Certainly there are some data government must have on us, for tax purposes, etc, but other than that, I feel only voluntary information should be kept. For instance, if we want medical care, records have to be kept,etc, but it is our choice to have the care. The rest quite worries me. And now that it’s becoming an information free-for-all …
Thanks for the kind words about the poem and story.
paisley said
once again your fiction made this post for me… couldn’t help but think about the actual metamorphose of that caterpillar into that butterfly as i read that poem tho…. i think i ruined the beauty in that transformation for myself by too close an introspection…….
anthonynorth said
Hi Paisley,
I’m glad you continue to enjoy my fiction. As for too much introspection, you can get addicted to it – believe me, I know! 🙂
lissa said
love the butterfly poem, reminds me of being a child, delighted by the sudden change, sweet
anthonynorth said
Hi Lissa,
Many thanks. I was, of course, inspired by the delightful prompt.
Inspiration Alley said
My husband and I have been talking about the whole Big Brother situation which is getting quite out of hand in England. It’s not only the information stored digitally on you, but the sheer number of times that you’re caught on camera if you go outside the door.It is now being questioned a bit more widely here, as our government has a habit of allowing our data to be compromised, lost or stolen and hence the whole story of protecting us from whatever source of evil is beginning to be questioned.
anthonynorth said
Hi Inspiration Alley,
Yes, in the average UK city you can be expected to be picked up on 300 cameras a day. A terrible situation. And data is constantly lost and stolen here, too.
David Mascellani said
Hi Tony
TONY ON DATA-TOTALITARIANISM & MORE –what you describe is very scary. Add multinational corporations with sociopaths in their ranks and global organized crime all vying for private information and it becomes terrifying.
WINDOWS ,
“Windows show how things can be,
allowing alternative ways to see,
the beauty of how others exist,
or horrors disclosed, they always persist;
But what if you’re neither here nor there,
just seeing a reflection when you stare,
caught in a world trapped in their glare,
a window to nothing from nowhere?
Shatter the glass! Escape! If you dare”
For me the above lines with their intermingling of pessimistic despair and optimistic hope are the theme for the four of your postings if they are read as one unit.
HANDYMAN – the cold, objective way you present this story gives it a chilling ‘Clockwork Orange’ feel. Impressive.
BUTTERFLY SKIES
A charming poem in its own right and a wonderful counterpoint to TONY ON DATA-TOTALITARIANISM & MORE
Cheer,
DavidM
anthonynorth said
Hi David,
Many thanks for that considered response. I always try to give a variation – more a ‘magazine’ than a post. And yes, you add another worrying aspect to the Data-Totalitarianism theme with global mafia. A good point.
Sue said
I enjoy staring out my window and watching the world go by 🙂 Happy TT and have a great rest of the week!
anthonynorth said
Hi Sue,
So do I. It’s a whole theatre of life out there.
Nicholas said
This is indeed problematic, and we should be worried, very worried. The thing that really infuriates me is the fatuous argument that if you aren’t up to anything illegal then you have nothing to worry about.
anthonynorth said
Hi Nicholas,
That argument is used a lot. And it stinks!
SJ Reidhead said
I don’t know if I like people who can write poetry! I’ve written one poem in my life. Ah well, we can’t do everything.
Good job.
SJR
The Pink Flamingo
anthonynorth said
Hi SJ,
Many thanks. I never wrote a poem until about a year ago, when I was challenged. I was surprised that people thought I could.
Adelle Laudan said
The Handyman … sad, but true! Excellent post, as always!
Happy T13!
anthonynorth said
Hi Adelle,
Thanks for that. Much appreciated.
Sherrie said
Hi!
If you stop to think about privacy, we really haven’t had any since they stuck a number to each of us. What number you ask? Social security numbers of course. Anyone can be found by social security, drivers license, and more I’m sure.
I really liked your butterfly poem. Beautiful! Take Care!!
Sherrie
anthonynorth said
Hi Sherrie,
This is very true. Some of these are demanded, whilst others we volunteer, such as for a driving licence. I suppose it comes down to a compromise – which I don’t think should involve a government’s right to extend that information beyond what it was given for.
Thanks for the kind words about the poem. I’m glad you enjoyed it 🙂
The Gal Herself said
Provocative line about windows — they always persist. The thought is both comforting, and spooky. (Thanks for visiting my TT)
anthonynorth said
Hi The Gal Herself,
Many thanks. Yes, they can be viewed both ways, depending on your outlook.
Sweet Talking Guy.. said
Hi Anthony, love the Butterfly Skies poem – the observation and the gradual realisation…
anthonynorth said
Hi Andy,
Thanks for that. Yes, I tried to encapsulate the life changing quality of it.
Forgetfulone said
Great poem for TT! Also lots of insight in your remarks about individualism and freedom.
anthonynorth said
Hi Forgetfulone,
Many thanks. Your comments are much appreciated.
stan said
Control, out of control.
2 sides to every story – then there’s the bit in the middle.
Too many ‘Jimmy’s’ around – they don’t all take this way out.
Butterflies – metamorphosis metaphor for confidence?
Heather said
Stopped by to see your TT, Impressed with all of your writing, freedom of thought is a wonderful thing.
tumblewords said
If I need to know something about me, I can find it in a stranger’s database. Cool. Recently listened to 1984 and it seemed so ‘yesterday’ in light of the lack of privacy we have today…whodathunk. The Windows is a nifty provocative poem and the Butterfly makes me think of lifting both feet off the floor to see what happens. Well, maybe not. Lovely both and the fiction is, again, real. Always a pleasure to stop by and have my mind stretched!
anthonynorth said
Hi Stan,
Control is, indeed, out of control, and no, not all Jimmys do this. Some still don’t get it.
Yes, I think the butterfly one is about confidence, too.
Hi Heather,
Thanks for that. I’m pleased you liked the post.
Hi Tumblewords,
Many thanks. And it’s always a pleasure to read your comments. And it’s always best to keep both feet on the ground 🙂
Linda Jacobs said
So many poems have been written about butterflies but yours seems fresh and different! I can see it as a children’s book!
anthonynorth said
Hi Linda,
Those are very kind words. Thank you so much.
Vera said
Ahh what a good take on windows! And Jimmy’s hands was well written.
Reading your butterfly poem somehow brought images of young street children who dream about rising above their situation, someday having the things that other, more fortunate children, have. it’s like seeing themselves someday having a normal life free from the clutches of poverty of misery. But i see it in their eyes too, that while they dream, they do not believe it may happen. And then years later, they find that it is possible – they can live the dream.
anthonynorth said
Hi Vera,
Thanks for that. That’s a good way of looking at it. The first thing that came into my mind when thinking about what to write from the prompt was The Ugly Duckling, which is about the same thing.
MeeAugraphie said
Privacy should be mine to give up only if I so choose; I suppose that is less a reality now.
A window to nothing from nowhere – love that phrase.
anthonynorth said
Hi MeeAugraphie,
It is indeed – even though it shouldn’t be. Many thanks for the kind words about the phrase.